Open circuit voltage reduction due to recombination at the heterojunction solar cell edge (2023)


The crystalline silicon (c-Si) based PV manufacturing technology experienced a well-defined trend in increasing the cells size, processing larger and larger wafers. Before the second half of years 2000 the standard wafer size was 10cm side (Pirozzi et al., 2006), in round shape for Floating Zone wafers, squared for multi crystalline or pseudo-squared wafers for Czochralski Silicon wafers (Vinod et al., 2000, Metz and Hezel, 2001, Chaoui et al., 2001). At laboratory level it was common to find quite small cells, from 1 to 5cm2, often obtained by producing chemical or mechanical trenches in the silicon wafer (Hamammu and Ibrahim, 2002; Gordon et al.,2006; Baliozian et al., 2020) or by cleaving larger cells (Guo et al., 2007), while large area cells were meant to be above 100cm2 (Gangopadhyay et al., 2006). With the strong impulse to the European and global PV production in the second half of years 2000, the industries and research centers started to work on 12.5 and 15.6cm side wafers, almost abandoning the small scale cells (Shirasawa, 2001, Mulligan et al., 2004, Erath et al., 2010). Recently, the standard wafer size is going toward M2 or M10, 156.75 and 182cm side length respectively, but with the aim of cutting them in half, or in smaller sizes, (Tonini et al., 2018, De Bastiani et al., 2021) or in half/three cut cell (Waqar Akram et al., 2020) to increase the module power output by the use of the shingling concept.

On the other hand, the growing interest in tandem devices, based on perovskites as top cell and c-Si as bottom cell, focused the attention on small-scale devices, with the highest efficiencies obtained on 1cm2 area cells both in stacked or monolithic configuration (Lamanna et al., 2020, Al-Ashouri et al., 2020, Green et al., 2022).

Nowadays, among c-Si based technologies, the amorphous silicon/crystalline silicon HeteroJunction (HJ) technology represents one of the best choices to achieve high efficiency solar cells (Yoshikawa et al., 2017). Its successful key factor is represented by the high open circuit voltage (Voc) achievable thanks to the excellent surface passivation provided by amorphous silicon (a-Si:H) (Taguchi, 2021). During cell manufacturing, the a-Si:H film deposition is performed on both c-Si wafer sides, and consequently also on the edges of the wafer, passivating all the three surfaces at the same time. However, when adopting the shingling concept, or when at laboratory level small cells are manufactured from larger wafers, the wafer edges result non-passivated. When a silicon edge is left uncovered by cutting, a recombining region is created due to the silicon non-passivated surface. This, in principle, leads to a reduction in the Voc of the cell, which is commonly observed in laboratories (Aberle et al., 1995; Ruhle et al., 1996; Altermatt et al., 1996, Guo et al., 2007).

Previous works already dealt with the analysis of edge recombination in cells where the emitter area was smaller than the total substrate surface, and did not reach the cell edge (Cuevas et al., 1981, Rhule et al., 1996, Altermatt et al., 1996). With this assumption, different models to take into account the recombination at the silicon exposed surfaces at the cell edges and in the neighbor regions were proposed. A comprehensive study was performed by Bertrand et al. (Bertrand et al., 2017) on laser scribed and cleaved Al-BSF solar cells, by introducing into the two- diodes model of the solar cell additional factors describing recombination mechanisms due to the cell surfaces, the junction, the area under the metallization and the bulk border of the cell, i.e. the non-passivated silicon at the cell edge. Nevertheless, due to the technology examined in the paper of Bertrand et al., the analysis needed to take into account the presence of one busbar in each cell; for this reason the conclusions presented in the work cannot be applied in the case of HJ solar cells, in which the surface recombination should be lower than in the Al-BSF ones. Nevertheless, the conclusion of Bertrand et al. was that the Voc drop is not significant for cells surfaces above 64cm2.

In the common practice by cleaving large area (M2- or M10-wafer based) heterojunction solar cells in half for their application into modules, no change, or only a minor decrease, in Voc values (and generally in the efficiency) is experienced, depending on the cutting method (Mehlich et al., 2016, Gérenton et al., 2020). However, there is not a precise indication in the literature about which area can be considered as suitably “large” for HJs.

The re-passivation of the cut edge of the cell could be considered as a viable way to recover and eventually further improve the performance of cut cells. Some studies were already performed on this topic (Münzer et al., 2021, Giglia et al., 2020) evidencing a benefit in the edge re-passivation, but with some concerns on the process to adopt. Another aspect to take into account with the silicon non-passivated surface at the cell edge is that it is not protected against the diffusion of any organic and metallic compound during module manufacturing or during the module life under the sun, also considering the effect of Potential Induced Degradation (Luo et al., 2017, Dong et al., 2018).

In this work, we have analyzed the correlation between the Voc, the cell area and the recombining surface introduced by cutting a cell into smaller ones and we have monitored the Voc as a function of the cell area during time. We have proposed a simplified model with three junctions in order to take into account the recombination enhancement at the edges of the HJ cell after the cut. We have also investigated the possibility of a re-passivation of the cell edges by depositing a thick a-Si:H layer after masking the cell front surface, with the aim of investigating the Voc stability to prevent diffusion of compounds from the uncovered Si areas.

We have also investigated different deposition conditions for the edge re-passivation layer in order to avoid possible thermal stresses to the a-Si:H layers in the cell with consequent modifications of their properties. The Voc monitoring has been carried out also as a function of time, for both cells having passivated and non-passivated edges.

Section snippets


Several small cells have been obtained by mechanically cleaving a heterojunction solar cell fabricated on a 243.36cm2 M2 n-type doped c-Si wafer. The full HJ cell was a conventional a-Si:H/c-Si bifacial solar cell, based on n-type 1–5Ω⋅cm wafer, 180µm thick. The sunward side was the base contact, with 4 metal busbars and 1.5mm spaced and 70µm wide grid fingers. Amorphous silicon thicknesses and TCO thickness were absolutely standard, as described, for example, in (Martini et al., 2020).

(Video) Solar Cell Circuit Model Explained

Voc vs area

The measured Voc values of all cells, both square and rectangular, are reported as a function of their area (A) and perimeter (P) in Fig. 1A and B respectively (blue squares). Both square and rectangular cells seem to share the same trend. The first noticeable result is the Voc reduction with decreasing cell area, as illustrated in Fig. 1A. It can be observed that after reducing the cell area from a full M2 size down to 25cm2 there is almost no change in Voc. For smaller device areas, down to


This paper investigates the open circuit voltage reduction observed when a silicon heterojunction cell is cut into smaller cells. The Voc reduction trend is undoubtedly due to the recombination at the cell edges, where a surface of non-passivated silicon is created along the cell perimeter.

The maximum voltage drop, from the full M2 wafer area down to 0.14cm2, has been evaluated in a 10% reduction of the starting value. There is a non-linear decrease of Voc with decreasing area, which allows

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.


This work was partly supported by the Italian Ministry of Economic Development in the framework of the Operating Agreement with ENEA for Research on the Electric System.

Recommended articles (6)

  • Research article

    A concentrating light multistage rising film solar distiller with a central cooling structure

    Solar Energy, Volume 257, 2023, pp. 96-109

    (Video) effect of recombination on solar cell performance: P1

    This paper presents a concentrating light multistage rising film solar distiller with a central cooling structure (RFSD). The RFSD mainly consists of the semicircular concentrator, a rising film device and a central cooling structure. The structure design of the semicircular concentrator is introduced in this paper. The relationship between the light receptivity of the semicircular concentrator and the solar incident angle was obtained by optical simulation. The mathematical model of RFSD was established, and the process of heat and mass transfer in RFSD was analyzed theoretically. Based on theoretical analysis, an experimental device was built. Furthermore, the device's water yield performance and energy utilization efficiency were tested under actual weather conditions. The experimental results show that when the average daily solar irradiance is 606.0 W/m2, the freshwater yielded by the device can reach 4450 g/m2, and the average daily efficiency is 81.6%. The comparison between the theoretical and experimental results shows that the theoretical model in this paper can well predict the device's operating parameters. The deviation of the theoretical operating temperature from the experimental value is within 2.3°C, and the deviation of the daily water yield efficiency is on a scale of 14.1% to 24.8%.

  • Research article

    Scalable and dynamically passive thermal regulation over solar wavelengths enabled by phase-transition metamaterials

    Solar Energy, Volume 257, 2023, pp. 257-265

    About 20% of all energy utilized worldwide is allocated to regulate the temperature of buildings through heating and cooling in response to seasonal changes. Numerous cutting-edge, low-carbon-footprint innovations have recently been demonstrated to assist resolve this issue, including passive radiative cooling and sun heating. Their accessibility is nevertheless constrained to particular seasons or climate zones by the steady and one-sided control of temperature. Here, taking advantage of recent breakthroughs in photonic manipulation and radiative heat transfer technology, we propose phase-transition metamaterials with dynamically passive and radiative thermal regulation capability for temperature control that can be scaled up for application in buildings. At a critical temperature, the sun absorptance of this metafilm can self-modulate from 0.9 to 0.18 as a result of temperature changes. This metafilm is made of reflective silver (Ag) thin film on top of polyethylene (PE) film with vanadium dioxide (VO2) nanoparticles embedded in it. By varying the volume percentages of the VO2 nanoparticles and the PE matrix thickness, this metafilm’s optical performance can be tailored. We model the inactive dynamic thermal regulator’s equilibrium temperature response to diurnal temperature swings. The industrial film extrusion approach has the potential to produce the nanoparticles embedded into the polymer structure, and the physical vapor deposition method can deposit the Ag thin film scalably, both of which are encouraging for scale-up deployment. This passive radiative heat thermal management technology can be potentially applied to regions with extreme annual temperature fluctuations.

  • Research article

    (Video) Energy levels, HOMO LUMO and recombination losses in perovskite solar cells

    Thermal performance enhancement on a box-type solar cooker using a triangular fin over a conventional cooking pot

    Solar Energy, 2023

    The thermal performance of existing box-type solar cookers is limited and to improve the performance many research works reported on modification of solar cooker sub-systems i.e., cylindrical fin over the cooking pot, extra air duct, integrating with a photovoltaic panel, incorporation of heat storage materials and multiple reflectors. This paper presents a novel study of a triangular-finned cooking pot to increase the convective heat transfer rate and solar irradiance over the cooking pot. The thermal network diagram is presented and thermal losses are measured using MATLAB. The thermal visualization is presented with the help of COMSOL Multiphysics 5.5 and uncertainty analysis of different performance parameters is completed with Engineering Equation Solver (EES). The simulation results found thermal losses occur from the top, bottom and side are 4.26, 0.77 and 0.64W/m2 respectively. The experimentally observed result indicates the cooking time is reduced from 94–95min to 85–86min during the boiling test of 1.5kg water for the triangular finned cooking pot. The first figure of merit is 0.139 and the second figure of merit is 0.563 respectively for the same loading conditions. The cooking power is increased from 68.71W to 77.06W. The thermal efficiency is increased from 36.16% to 40.55%. The uncertainty analysis emphasizes the value of the performance parameter lies within an acceptable range. From thermal visualization, It is concluded that wall edges are less affected by heat flow and the correct placement of the cooking pot is necessary for uniform heating.

  • Research article

    Efficient ternary active layer materials for organic photovoltaics

    Solar Energy, Volume 257, 2023, pp. 324-343

    In recent years, ternary organic solar cells (OSCs) emerged as a potential candidate in photovoltaic-technology to constantly refresh the devices' power conversion efficiency (PCE). The introduction of ternary components (polymer or small molecule) proved a facile and practical approach to overcome the performances of binary-OSCs, increased mechanical-flexibility, provided ease in fabrication, made them light-weight, and mutually combined the merits of single-junction and tandem solar cells. Recently, the insertion of small molecule and non-fullerene acceptors into the binary blend is considered a most promising strategy to fabricate highly efficient ternary OSCs devices. To date, the PCE has reached 19%, that opened the track for the commercialization of OSCs. In this review article, we will firstly present basic working principles of ternary OSCs, followed by recent trends and strategies settled for selecting ternary-components. For ternary architecture, we discussed the basic role of third-component, progress and prospect of non-fullerene acceptors, solution-processed non-fullerene acceptor, morphology optimization, the ratio of each component, and the miscibility of nanostructure. Then we summarize the key progresses achieved with different types of ternary OSCs based on polymer, small molecules (SMs), and non-fullerene acceptors (NFAs). At end, we deduce with a summary and challenges of different types of ternary OSCs.

    (Video) Equivalent circuit of a solar cell

  • Research article

    Fabrication of DSSC based on Capsicum annuum and Tamarindus indica plant seeds extract as natural photosensitizers

    Solar Energy, Volume 257, 2023, pp. 314-323

    Twelve dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs) were fabricated using Capsicum annuum and Tamarindus indica seeds extract as natural photosensitizing dyes. Zinc oxide-based three different films were employed as charge transporters, whereas graphite and PEDOT:PSS were adopted as electrode materials. The optical character of natural dyes and zinc oxide-based layers was obtained by UV–vis spectroscopy. Structural information was achieved by X-ray diffraction and modes of vibrations were obtained by Fourier Transform IR spectroscopy. Different schemes of DSSCs were considered by choosing from metal oxide films, seed extract, and electrode material. J-V curves recorded for all the DSSCs-configurations revealed that the maximum power conversion efficiency of 1.65% was found in the case of DSSC which comprised Capsicum annuum (dye), zinc oxide, and graphite as an electrode. Minimum 0.43% efficiency was obtained for the DSSC based on Capsicum annuum as a dye, Al-doped zinc oxide film, and PEDOT:PSS as an electrode. This study is a way forward to using recyclable natural resources for sustainable and economical solar power conversion devices.

  • Research article

    Improved contact quality for silver-free silicon heterojunction solar cells by phosphoric acid treatment

    Solar Energy, Volume 252, 2023, pp. 1-7

    Electroplating technology is considered as a promising alternative to low-temperature sintered silver pastes for the purpose of significantly reducing the cost of silicon heterojunction (SHJ) solar cells (SCs). However, achieving excellent contact quality between the plated grid and indium tin oxide (ITO) remains a big challenge to satisfy the requirements for fabrication and high performance. In this work, phosphoric acid (H3PO4) is used to modify the ITO surface to improve the contact quality of the plated grid/ITO and enhance the performance of SHJ SCs. It is found that the phosphate groups are adsorbed on the ITO surface to form a dipole layer after H3PO4 treatment. The wettability of H3PO4-treated ITO is substantially improved, resulting in a pinhole-free electroplated nickel (Ni) seed layer. Moreover, the work function of ITO rises by approximately 0.2eV, which reduces the contact potential barrier between the ITO and the metal electrode. The contact resistivity (ρc) between the plated grid and H3PO4-treated ITO is reduced to approximately 0.4mΩ·cm2, compared to 1.5 mΩ·cm2 of the control sample. In addition, the metal grid formed on the H3PO4-treated ITO exhibits a better uniformity. Finally, the SHJ cell with H3PO4 treatment process receives a remarkable power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 23.19%, which is approximately 1% (absolute) higher than that of the control device. Therefore, we demonstrate that modifying ITO by H3PO4 is a promising way to improve the contact quality for the electroplating metallization in SHJ SCs.

    (Video) Heterojuntions

© 2023 International Solar Energy Society. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.


1. SoT EED 6th Semester.. Renewable Energy Engineering Dr Siddharth Joshi
(School of Technology PDPU)
2. Solar Cells Lecture 2: Physics of Crystalline Solar Cells
3. Additional optical and electrical losses in solar cells
(PV1x Solar Energy Engineering: Photovoltaic Energy Conversion)
4. 16. Solar Cell Characterization
(MIT OpenCourseWare)
5. Transport and recombination in polymer:fullerene bulk heterojunction solar cells - Paul Blom
(The Institute for Energy Efficiency)
6. 8. Toward a 1D Device Model, Part II: Material Fundamentals
(MIT OpenCourseWare)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Last Updated: 06/24/2023

Views: 6174

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Birthday: 1995-01-14

Address: 55021 Usha Garden, North Larisa, DE 19209

Phone: +6812240846623

Job: Corporate Healthcare Strategist

Hobby: Singing, Listening to music, Rafting, LARPing, Gardening, Quilting, Rappelling

Introduction: My name is Foster Heidenreich CPA, I am a delightful, quaint, glorious, quaint, faithful, enchanting, fine person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.